All Abby Strickland wants to do for the holidays is relax, read a good book, and spend time with her puppy, Simon. Maybe even spend some time with the handsome Ryan. But when a sterling silver chalice disappears from the local church, Abby is drawn into the investigation due to her expertise in sterling silver. The Chief of Police asks for her help, which she reluctantly gives, and tries to help solve the puzzles that are uncovered.